Hey fellow collectors! I’ve recently been diving into the fascinating world of the D over S coins, and I must say, I’m pretty intrigued by their rarity and market value. I stumbled upon a D over S penny in fairly good condition at a local show—just a few minor scratches, but that detail makes it even more special, doesn’t it?
In my research, I’ve come across some mixed opinions about how much these coins actually fetch. Certain sellers boast about getting a premium price due to their unique characteristics, while others suggest the market’s more subdued than expected. I’m curious about your experiences! Have you bought or sold a D over S coin lately? What condition was it in, and what sort of price did you see?
I’d love to hear about any personal stories or tips regarding the buying and selling of these coins. Do you think their value has been increasing, or are we seeing a plateau? Let’s share our insights and maybe help each other out in our collecting journey!
The D over S coins, particularly the 1916 D over S penny, have well-documented market quirks. In high grades, they can fetch a premium, often going for hundreds to thousands of dollars depending on condition. From my experience, I bought a VF-25 (Very Fine) once for about $150 and sold it for $300 a couple of years later.
Here are some factors impacting their value:
- Grade: High grades (like MS-65 or higher) can dramatically increase prices.
- Market Demand: Certain times see spikes, especially during coin shows.
- Historical Context: The stories behind these coins can add sentimental value to buyers.
Keep an eye on recent auction results—they can be a good indicator of current market trends. I recommend checking out sites like
PCGS for more data on pricing trends. Overall, being well-informed and patient is key in this hobby!
8 Likes
Thanks for your detailed insights, @CoinExpertGuy! I think my penny has the potential to reach that VF-25 grade. It’s interesting how the market can shift based on demand. Have you noticed any trends in the last year?
2 Likes
I’ve had a D over S penny sitting in my collection for years! I thought about selling it at a recent local show, but I got cold feet and ended up keeping it. It’s tough to part with such a unique coin! If anyone’s interested, I might be willing to trade. 
What kind of trades have others done?
5 Likes
@CollectorChris I totally get that! D over S coins are unique in their own right. I traded a lower-grade version for a rare mint set last year. You should definitely consider the potential of what you might be trading up for.
3 Likes
Hey everyone! I previously sold a D over S penny on a popular auction site. It was graded MS-63 and fetched around $500. I think the secret lies in presenting coins well and having clear, high-quality images. What do you all think? Is it worth the investment for good photography?
6 Likes
I absolutely agree, @NumismaticNerd! Quality presentation can make or break a sale. I also find that writing a good description with historical context on how the D over S happened can engage potential buyers, thus increasing interest in the coin itself!
4 Likes
Yes! Context adds so much value! 
Does anyone here know if the rarity is greater for certain years? I’ve seen some 1916 D and 1922 D over S pennies almost reach $1K in auctions!
7 Likes
I recently found a D over S penny myself! It’s got some scratches but still presents well. I’m contemplating whether to send it for grading. Would you all advise it, or is the cost not worth it for a lower grade? 
3 Likes
@PennySleuth I would say it really depends on the condition and visible wear. If it’s anything below a VF-30, you might find that the costs exceed what you’ll get back. Grading fees can add up quickly! If it’s in better shape, definitely consider it! It’s always a risk/reward situation.
2 Likes
I’ve been collecting D over S coins for about 5 years now, and I must say, these coins never cease to impress. There’s just something magical about them— the history, the craftsmanship, and the stories behind each piece. What makes you all passionate about collecting these?
1 Like