Hey fellow collectors! I’ve recently taken a keen interest in DMPL (Deep Mirror Proof Like) coins, and I’ve been diving into the specifics around their condition and value. The depth of the mirrors and, of course, the presence of any blemishes or marks really seems to play a huge role in their overall desirability.
I came across a few DMPL examples at a local coin show last weekend that left me both excited and a bit puzzled. One of them had an almost perfect mirror finish but a small contact mark on the cheek, which had me questioning its true value. From my research, it seems that even minor imperfections can significantly affect the price, but I’d love to hear about your experiences. What specific aspects of DMPL coins do you consider most valuable?
Are there particular grading details or marketplaces you trust? If anyone has tips for spotting high-quality DMPL coins or even horror stories from bad trades, please share! Looking forward to your insights!
Absolutely! DMPL coins are fascinating. One of the main aspects to consider is the depth of the mirror finish. The more reflective the fields, the better! I usually look for coins with a high degree of contrast between the mirror fields and the details because it enhances their aesthetic appeal and value. In my experience, the presence of contact marks, like the one you mentioned, greatly affects the grading. Even a small blemish can bring the grade down significantly, from a potential 68 to a 64 or lower, which can lead to sizeable price differences.
- Also, consider the strike quality. A well-struck DMPL will have raised details that are sharper and more defined.
- Lastly, I trust PCGS and NGC for grading as they have a solid reputation in the industry.
If you get a chance, you might want to look into this recent article on
PCGS about DMPL coins for more insights!
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed response, @SilverSeeker78! That contrast tip is really helpful. I’ll definitely look more closely at the strikes during my next meet. What about how you address imperfections? Do you think some can be overlooked, or is it usually a deal-breaker?
2 Likes
Understanding DMPL coins can be tricky! I’ve been collecting them for years, and I always recommend looking at the finish under different lighting. Sometimes the true surface flaws can hide, especially in typical display lights. The market can be finicky, so understanding your target grade is crucial when buying. For example, I once purchased a DMPL with what I thought was minimal blemishes, but later found out it was more like a 63 instead of a 67 — sold it for a loss! As for marketplaces, I tend to stick to NGC events or their certified listings, as they’re quite reliable.
3 Likes
Great point, @NumismaticsNerd! Lighting definitely plays a big role. I never considered that before. Would you say that certain coins are more prone to these hidden flaws than others?
1 Like
Deep Mirror Proof Like coins are intriguing! I’ve had my share of both successes and heartbreaks trading them. I once traded a DMPL that I thought was flawless, only to discover a little scratch that I missed. It cost me dearly when I tried to sell it later. Make sure you have a jeweler’s loupe handy to inspect your treasures. At the end of the day, the thrill of the hunt is what keeps us collectors going! Have you checked out any online venues like eBay? Just be careful with sellers without ratings!
4 Likes
Spot on, @CollectorChris! Use the loupe! And remember, no coin is worth risking your reputation over a deal. If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. I had a horror story with an ungraded DMPL that was mislabeled as perfect; turned out it had a major scratch not visible in the picture. Lesson learned! Trust your instincts and always ask for better pics or a return policy.
2 Likes
I’m interested too! Does anyone have recommendations on books or resources specifically around DMPL coins? I’d love to have some dedicated reading material. US Mint offers some guides that might be helpful as well!
3 Likes
@CuriousCollector101, I highly recommend “The Complete Guide to DMPL Coins” by Scott T. Shapiro. It covers grading specifics and market trends in-depth. As for online resources, you might want to join Coin World, which has fantastic articles and forums. Plus, the community is pretty active. Don’t hesitate to ask questions there!
4 Likes
Lightheartedly, I always say, patience is a virtue—especially when it comes to DMPL coins! I’ve waited months to find the perfect example without any marks. The thrill of the chase is what makes it all worthwhile, right? Just don’t rush into a trade because you’re excited; sometimes the best coins take time to find!
2 Likes
Wise words, @EagleEyeJohn! I think I might have rushed through a couple of recent purchases. I’ll take my time from now on and really inspect what I’m getting. Appreciate everyone’s insights so far!
6 Likes