Hey everyone! I just wanted to share my recent experience with having my 1937 Fraser Buffalo graded. I’ve been collecting these gems for a few years now, and this particular one was a family heirloom passed down to me. I was pretty confident about its condition, but when I took it to my local shop, I was gobsmacked by the grading results!
To my surprise, the coin came back as a MS-64. For some reason, I was expecting a higher grade, given its shiny luster and minimal scratches. It definitely has some bag marks that I overlooked when I first assessed it under my loupe. I had done a fair bit of research on grading standards, but the nuances of how light reflections and tiny imperfections affect the overall grade caught me off guard.
I’m curious, has anyone else had a similar experience when grading Fraser Buffalos or any other coins? What common pitfalls should I watch out for when assessing the condition of my coins? Also, how much weight do you think grading fees play into whether to get a coin graded? Looking forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences!
Grading coins can be quite a challenge! Your experience resonates with many in the coin collecting community. The Fraser Buffalo is known for its beauty, but like you said, those subtle bag marks can really affect the grade. I’ve had a similar experience with my buffalo nickels—I thought I was holding a gem, but the professionals had a different opinion! It’s essential to understand that coin grading is not just about what we see but also how we understand the grading process. May I suggest checking out resources like PCGS or NGC for detailed grading standards? They often help clarify those nuances you’ve encountered!
2 Likes
Thanks for sharing your insights, @NumismaticNerd! I appreciate the links to PCGS and NGC. It’s definitely tough to navigate grading standards. I read about the differences in perspective when it comes to judging luster versus surface marks. Are there any specific signs or characteristics you look for now before getting a coin graded?
1 Like
It’s always surprising how subjective grading can be! I had a 1936 Fraser Buffalo that I thought was at least a MS-65, but it came back as an MS-63 due to some overlooked scratches. I learned that light reflection plays a huge role in how professionals evaluate coins. Have you considered sending your coin to a grading service that specializes in rare coins? It might provide you with a second opinion. Next time, maybe I’ll try grading with an established service first.
3 Likes
Absolutely! I think many of us have faced that shock at grading. I had my eye on a Buffalo and thought it was pristine until I took it for grading. You might want to look into USMint for their collection—it’s fascinating! Also, have you thought about whether the grading fees are worth it? It’s a tough call sometimes, especially for personal pieces with sentimental value.
1 Like
Great point, @CoinConscious! The fees can be daunting, especially when it’s a family heirloom. I guess sentimental value can sometimes outweigh the cost, but it also makes me question if I should invest more into grading other coins. Do you have any tips for determining whether to grade a coin or not?
2 Likes
Just remember—getting graded is like going to a fancy restaurant. You’re paying for the presentation! 
So if it’s just for a personal collection and holds value in your heart, maybe hold off on the grading? Unless you’re planning to sell, then get that shiny grade! What do you think?
Haha! Love that analogy! @CollectibleComedy, you’re so right! The presentation does matter, especially with coins that carry history. What a balancing act it is between heart and investment! Do you have a collection that you wish hadn’t been graded? Just curious!
Grading can be tricky! I always recommend examining coins under different lighting conditions before making an assessment. Natural light often reveals details that artificial lighting can hide. Have you tried exclusively using a loop in bright sunlight?
3 Likes
That’s a solid tip, @SharpEye! Lighting definitely affects what you see. I appreciate all these insights! Is there a particular grading service you’d recommend based on your experiences?
1 Like