Hey everyone! I’ve been diving deeper into the world of error coins lately, and I can’t help but notice the buzz around repunched dates (RPDs). Just last week, I picked up an 1882 Indian Head cent with a minor RPD, and it got me thinking: Are these quirky variations becoming less popular among collectors, or is there still a strong desire for them?
From what I’ve seen at various forums and shows, RPDs don’t seem to command the same attention as they did a few years back. My piece, although in decent condition—I’d rate it as XF—doesn’t exactly inspire awe. I remember the days when collectors would fawn over any sign of a repunched date, but now it feels a bit more niche. I’ve done some digging into recent auction results and found that RPDs are often overshadowed by more eye-catching varieties.
What do you all think? Are repunched dates still a valuable part of your collection, or are you leaning more toward unique errors like double dies or off-centers? I’d love to hear your experiences and thoughts! Do you think the excitement around RPDs is on the decline, or is it just a matter of finding the right pieces?
Let’s discuss!
Great discussion starter, @CoinEnthusiast42! I feel like RPDs have definitely lost some of their charm over the years. Collectors seem more focused on high-end varieties now, like the 1796 Draped Bust or 1916-D Mercury Dime. In fact, I just sold my 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln cent, and the buyer seemed more excited about the double die they were working on than my RPD piece from the late 1800s.
That said, I do think RPDs can still be fascinating if they have a unique or prominent error. It’s all about the rarity and the story behind the coin! Have you noticed any specific trends in auction prices lately? I’d love to hear more about what you found in your digging!
3 Likes
I think it really depends on the collector. Some are drawn to the more spectacular mistakes like the classic double dies. However, RPDs still hold a special place! I’ve found that a well-defined RPD can fetch a decent price, especially if it’s graded high, like MS65.
I picked up an RPD 1856 Flying Eagle cent last year, and it’s one of my favorites. The subtlety and history are what I cherish. Collecting is subjective! What matters is what we, as collectors, value, right?
2 Likes
Thanks for your insights, @CoinCollector99! It’s interesting to hear how buyers are shifting focus in today’s market. The rarity plays such a crucial role, especially when it comes to auction results. I’ve been looking into some error coin trends on PCGS, and it looks like unique varieties often outperform the market.
I do wonder, though, if RPDs have become a bit like ‘entry-level errors.’ They might not have the same thrill as some high-profile pieces, but they could still be a worthwhile area for new collectors to explore. What do you think?
1 Like
Honestly, @CoinEnthusiast42, I’ve always loved the quirks of RPDs. The fact that these little details can be overlooked by many collectors makes them unique finds!
Sure, they might not have as flashy a reputation as double dies, but I think they have their own charm. Plus, if you can snag a good one for a decent price, that’s a win in my book. What about shows or online auctions—have you seen any recent examples that caught your eye?
4 Likes
I agree, @NumismaticNerd! It’s about what excites the collector. I’ve seen collectors who are just starting their journeys gravitating towards RPDs since they often have more affordable options compared to those big-ticket items. Just yesterday, I picked up an interesting RPD, and honestly, it feels satisfying to uncover these less sought-after errors.
It’s nice to have a mix in your collection, and you never know what might become desirable in the future!
3 Likes
@OldCoinGuy, I think you hit the nail on the head! Many collectors often overlook RPDs because they don’t pop as much as other errors. However, for true enthusiasts, the narrative behind the coin adds immense value. It’s like hunting for hidden treasure! Just the other week at a coin show, I stumbled upon a rare RPD, and it felt like finding a gem! Do you often check shows for errors like this?
5 Likes
Right on, @DiggerDave! Finding that ‘hidden treasure’ element really is what keeps the thrill alive in collecting. And yes, I’ve been frequenting a lot of local shows lately. Surprisingly, I’ve seen a few dealers with RPDs who are still asking for a premium, which indicates there’s a niche market still thriving. What have been your favorite finds at shows? I’d love to hear your stories!
2 Likes
I think RPDs are still a great addition to any collection! While they might not be as glamorous as some other errors, there’s something almost poetic about their stories. Each coin has gone through a process, and these little errors make them unique.
Just the other day, I was looking at my RPD, and I could feel the history behind it! What’s the oldest RPD in your collection?
3 Likes
I think RPDs have their merit! It’s interesting how trends can shift so rapidly. What was once highly sought after can easily fade. I remember a few years back, RPDs were featured in all the big forums! Now they’re barely a niche. But who knows? Their time may come back eventually!
Moreover, I find them a fun area of study as well; every RPD is unique! Anyone else here have a favorite RPD piece they’re proud of?
1 Like
I think it’s all about education. Many new collectors may not understand the appeal of classic errors like RPDs. Grading can also affect interest—the higher the grade, the more exciting it becomes.
I love to pull out my RPD and share the story behind it! So many collectors focus on the flashiest errors, but I see value in the subtler pieces. It creates fantastic conversations at shows!
3 Likes
Hey, everyone! RPDs are kinda like the underdogs of the coin world, right?
Sure, they may not be the brightest stars, but give them a little love, and they shine in their own way! It’s all about perspective! Anyone else have any jokes about coin collecting? I could use a good laugh!