Hey folks! I recently found myself in a bit of a pickle regarding how to submit some of my coins for grading. I’ve got a small collection of vintage silver dollars that I’ve been keeping in good condition, and I’m torn between using a professional service or trying to rally a few collector friends for a group submission.
On one hand, I’ve heard that professionals can really help maximize the value, especially if they have experience with specific types of coins. The flip side is that it can be pricey and I worry that I might miss out on savings by not pooling resources with my buddies. I’ve done some research on submission fees and turnaround times, and honestly, the thought of coordinating everything myself is a bit daunting. Has anyone been in a similar situation?
I’d love to hear your experiences! What benefits did you find when using a professional? Or did organizing a group submission work well for you? Let’s discuss the pros and cons of both approaches!
Great topic! I’ve been in the same situation with my collection of Morgan silver dollars. I opted for a professional service like PCGS after hearing some positive experiences from other collectors.
- They provide detailed grading, which enhances the resale value of the coins.
- Their expertise helps in identifying any flaws that I might have missed.
- Turnaround times can vary, but I found it well worth it for the peace of mind.
I’d recommend doing your research to find a service that has good reviews specifically for your coin types. Overall, I think the investment in a professional grading service pays off, especially when dealing with higher-value coins. Good luck with your decision!
5 Likes
Hi @coin_enthusiast_123! I totally understand your dilemma. I tried organizing a group submission with some friends. It was a fun experience, but it had its challenges.
- Communication was tricky, and organizing payment was messy.
- We ended up with different turnaround times, which confused us about tracking our submissions.
In the end, while we saved a bit on submission costs, I think we missed out on the expertise that a professional submission would provide. Just something to consider!
3 Likes
Thanks for sharing, @silver_hound! It sounds like the group submission had both pros and cons. I’m leaning towards a professional service, especially for the reasons you mentioned about communication. I’d love to hear from others if they had different experiences with group submissions.
1 Like
I’ve always gone with professionals, like NGC. They make the entire process hassle-free. Sure, it costs more, but you get what you pay for! The detailed certifications they provide are crucial for long-term value appreciation.
4 Likes
Absolutely, @collectible_panda! Plus, you can use it as a learning experience. The feedback from the experts can really give you insights into what to look for in your next purchases! Still, I think group submissions can be more enjoyable if you have a good circle of friends who know their stuff.
2 Likes
I actually prefer group submissions for lower-value coins. It’s all about maximizing value for larger investments. I’ve had some fun experiences where we’d all send something, and then have a mini party when the grades come back. 
Just make sure to set clear rules!
3 Likes
@coin_junkie_45, that sounds like a blast! I like the idea of celebrating the grades. Do you have any tips on how to set those clear rules to avoid confusion?
For sure, @coin_enthusiast_123! Here are some tips:
- Everyone should agree on the coins being submitted.
- Decide upfront on the submission fees and who covers what.
- Set a timeline for submission and for when to expect grades back.
It really helps to have a plan. Also, Google Hangouts worked great for us to discuss details! Good luck!
2 Likes
Great tips, @coin_junkie_45! I’ve been thinking about that too. Maybe we can work towards a snowball affect—start with a few and grow our submissions as we gain trust in the process!
1 Like
I’ve used both routes. Personally, I prefer professionals for unique or rare coins due to their expertise. But group submissions are a great way to socialize and learn together! You could always try a mix—start with some coins in a group and send your rarer pieces through a professional. Just make sure to research on sites like US Mint for authenticity!
5 Likes