Hey everyone! I’ve been diving deeper into the world of coin grading lately, and I can’t help but wonder if there are specific coins that tend to fetch higher prices depending on whether they’re graded by PCGS or NGC. It’s fascinating how two leading services can sometimes impact a coin’s value so differently.
Recently, I picked up a couple of Peace Dollars—one graded by PCGS and the other by NGC. The PCGS coin is in a solid MS65 condition, while the NGC one is an MS64. I did some research and noticed that in general, many collectors seem to prefer PCGS for certain dates, especially with higher-grade pieces. However, I’ve also seen some sellers enjoy a premium on NGC coins, particularly for older or rare types.
How do you all feel about the grading services? Do you think there are certain types of coins that are more valuable when graded by one over the other? What should I be looking for in terms of market trends? Let’s share our thoughts and experiences!
Great topic, CoinCollector87! In my experience, certain coins do indeed fetch higher prices depending on whether they are graded by PCGS or NGC. For example, Santos-Dumont Double Eagles often see stronger prices with PCGS, especially in higher grades like MS66 or MS67. There’s a palpable preference in the market for PCGS among dealers, particularly for more modern issues and a few select classics. Peace Dollars generally have a solid market regardless of the grading service, but you’re correct in observing that collector sentiment can vary based on grade.
- Look for items like:
- Early gold coins
- High-grade silver dollars
- Limited mintage modern coins
It’s always wise to check completed auction listings and see which service has been commanding higher prices. You might want to refer to the
PCGS website for insights on market trends and how different coins are performing. Let’s keep this discussion going!
5 Likes
Thanks for the insights, NumismaticNerd! I’ve been tracking those double eagles closely. It’s interesting how much the grading service can impact a coin’s value. It feels like a popularity contest sometimes! I’m particularly curious about coins that might be undervalued with one service versus another. Any thoughts on that?
2 Likes
Hey CoinCollector87! I’ve noticed the same trend with Mercury Dimes. Sometimes coins graded by NGC can fetch a higher price, especially in lower grades. It really depends on the market dynamics and the buyers’ preferences—some collectors are strictly loyal to one grading service. Always good to check the NGC site for updates on their popular series!
3 Likes
I’ve found that Barber Quarters tend to go for lower prices when graded by NGC, even if the condition is comparable to PCGS. Maybe it’s an image issue? Dealers often trust PCGS more for coins from this era.
2 Likes
To add to this discussion: I think the older coins hold more value in the NGC slab, especially key dates and rarities. I’ve scored big on some Seated Liberty coins graded by NGC—many collectors still prefer them. Plus, they’ve got some nice color to them when preserved right. But always be cautious. Remember, prices fluctuate, so check your data often!
4 Likes
Why did the coin collector break up? Because he found her too graded! 
But seriously, I think a lot of this comes down to personal preferences. I always look at the luster—if a coin has that beautiful sheen, it can sway my opinion on the grading service, regardless of the slab.
1 Like
Haha, good one, TheJokerCoin! I definitely agree that luster is super important! Anyone have recent examples of coins they bought that surprised them in terms of grading service value?
3 Likes
Just last week, I snagged a 1921 Peace Dollar in an NGC slab for a price that seemed low for its condition. I got it scored at MS65 and have seen similar coins in PCGS getting listed for way more! It’ll be interesting to see how it performs in the next few months.
5 Likes
Coin grading can be quite subjective. Factors such as market trends, the specific date of the coin, and the current demand can shift values significantly. Sometimes, I find myself paying up for NGC slabs, particularly for coins with nice toning. There’s definitely a bias towards the luster, and while PCGS has that greater market acceptance, NGC has its loyalists that swear by its integrity in grading older coins. The competition is compelling!
6 Likes
Exactly, RareCoinGuy! It’s fascinating how trends can emerge based on events like auctions or featured coins. That said, I think the real key is understanding who your buyer is when it comes time to sell. If they’re in the PCGS camp, it might be tough to get a premium on an NGC slab, and vice versa. What strategies do you guys use when deciding which service to go with?
4 Likes