Hey everyone! As a passionate collector of Weinman design coins, I’ve been diving deep into the authentication process lately. I recently picked up a beautiful Walking Liberty half dollar from 1936, and while the seller seemed reputable, I couldn’t shake that feeling of wanting to double-check its authenticity. With counterfeits becoming increasingly sophisticated, I thought it would be a great idea to share tips and experiences.
What methods do you all use to verify these coins? Personally, I always rely on the weight and diameter measurements first, since the original specs are pretty well-documented. I’ve also dug into resources like PCGS and NGC for their guides on common fakes, which has been super helpful. Plus, I love looking at the finer details like the luster and the design elements—sometimes you can just tell when something feels “off.” I’m eager to hear about your personal experiences and what tools or techniques you’ve found most effective!
Are there specific things you watch for when examining Weinman coins? Do any of you use magnification tools or even software for analysis? I’d love to gather some collective wisdom on this!
Great topic, SilverSeeker99! I totally agree that the weight and diameter are critical first steps in the authentication process. For Walking Liberty half dollars, the standard diameter is 30.6 mm, and they should weigh about 12.5 grams. Any discrepancies here should raise red flags. Additionally, I like to use a jeweler’s loupe for visual inspection.
- Look for inconsistency in the design - especially around the inscriptions.
- Examine the edge; authentic coins have a smooth edge, while counterfeits might show roughness or noticeable flaws.
- The feel of the coin is also important; genuine coins typically have a certain heft and texture.
I’ve had success with this method many times. I’ve heard software analysis can be useful too, especially for beginners! Any recommendations on good software? Thanks for sharing your insights on this!
5 Likes
Thanks for jumping in, @CoinMaster21! I appreciate the detailed breakdown. I hadn’t thought about checking the edge specifically—definitely a great point. As for software, I’ve heard good things about Nawcc’s digital tools for comparative analysis. I’ll look more into that!
1 Like
Interesting discussion! I’ve been collecting for decades and can confidently say that visual inspection and expert opinion are crucial. I often take my coins to local shows where I can consult with experts. They can spot things you might miss. Trust your instincts—if something feels off, it probably is. And don’t hesitate to ask for a second opinion! What’s your experience with sending coins for grading? Have any of you used NGC or PCGS services?
3 Likes
I’ve sent a few coins to both NGC and PCGS. The turnaround time was a bit long but worth it for peace of mind! They provide detailed reports that can really help in understanding the coin’s value as well. I recently sent a 1945 Walker and was thrilled with the grade. Just be sure to package them securely! Have you all had any issues with shipping?
3 Likes
When it comes to examining these beautiful Weinman coins, I always make use of magnification tools. I bought a decent digital microscope that connects to my computer, which provides fantastic detail. Subtle features, like the hair strands on Lady Liberty, can differentiate a counterfeit from the real deal. Also, I prefer to check for any signs of wear since many counterfeits are poorly aged. Anyone else using similar devices?
5 Likes
I totally agree, @NumismaticNerd! Those digital microscopes are game-changers! I found one for a reasonable price on Amazon. Being able to zoom in on those tiny details has made my authentication process much easier. Plus, nothing beats being able to see all the design intricacies in high resolution! It’s almost like having a piece of history right in your hands. 
5 Likes
Why did the coin collector break up with their partner?
They found her too “counterfeit”! 
But for real, it’s essential to know your coins and feel confident in them, especially with those pesky fakes out there. Keep up the good discussions—learning a lot from everyone!
8 Likes
I just looked up the PCGS site, and they have some great resources! Thanks for the suggestion, @SilverSeeker99. I’ll definitely be referencing their guides on recognizing fakes more often. The wealth of information out there is incredible!
2 Likes
Shipping can be a nightmare! I’ve had coins go missing in transit before. Now, I always use registered mail and ensure they are well-insured. Never skimp on safety—that’s the golden rule of shipping valuable coins. What’s the best strategy you guys have? Would love to hear everyone’s thoughts!
4 Likes
I often use NGC’s website as well. They update their guides frequently, and it’s super user-friendly. Plus, their forums have awesome discussions just like this one! Definitely recommend checking them out for anyone wanting to dive deeper into coin authentication.
2 Likes