Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been diving into my collection lately, and I’ve got a couple of early release coins that I’m considering selling. One is a 2022 Proof Silver Eagle—gorgeous condition with a deep cameo finish—and I’m really curious about what others have experienced in the selling process.
I’ve done some research on platforms like eBay and Etsy, but I wanted to hear from you all. Have any of you had luck selling early releases there, or did you find other platforms more successful? I’m particularly interested in how you approached pricing and marketing those coins, especially since certain early releases can be quite sought after.
So, what has been your experience? Any tips on platforms you’ve found to yield better results? Do you usually see higher bids closer to release dates, or is there a sweet spot to list them? I’m eager to learn from your experiences and stories!
Absolutely! Selling early release coins can be both rewarding and tricky. I sold a 2021 Proof Silver Eagle last year, and honestly, eBay worked wonders for me. I found that using high-quality images and providing detailed descriptions really attracted buyers. I included technical details like the coin’s condition—i.e., my coin was graded as PR70—in the title. This helped it stand out among other listings.
Also, I learned that timing is crucial. I listed mine about a month after its release, which brought in higher bids as collectors were still excited about having it. Here’s the full breakdown of my experience:
- Use high-resolution photos.
- Highlight unique features (like the deep cameo finish).
- Set a fair starting price but allow for bidding.
I’d love to hear if others have seen similar results or had different experiences!
10 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experience, @NumisNerd42! Your tips are super helpful. I’m especially interested in the timing aspect—you mentioned listing after a month. Do you think starting with a lower initial bid might grab attention, or would that risk undervaluing the coin?
3 Likes
I personally prefer Etsy for selling coins. While it’s more focused on art and handmade goods, I’ve seen an increase in collectors searching there for early releases. Just ensure you list your items in the right categories. A well-crafted listing will attract buyers.
Pricing is key. Base your price off of recent sales of similar coins, and don’t forget to factor in shipping costs. I’ve found that being clear about shipping times is appreciated by buyers. Here’s a link to check market trends on NGC: it helps gauge the right pricing! Good luck!
5 Likes
For selling early releases, I would definitely recommend checking out Facebook groups. The community is often looking for early releases, and I’ve had great success there. Just be cautious about payment methods to avoid scams!
7 Likes
Great question, @CoinHustler89! Starting with a low bid can stir interest, but it can also backfire if collectors see it as a sign that the coin isn’t in demand. I’d suggest starting it at a price you’d be happy with since it’s always best to set a floor. Stay aware of similar listings as well; sometimes a little competition can drive your price higher than expected!
4 Likes
Thanks, @SilverSeekers! I hadn’t considered Facebook groups before. Do you have any specific groups you’d recommend? I’m all for expanding my selling strategies!
2 Likes
I’ve had experiences with pricing based on grades. For instance, my 2022 Proof Silver Eagle sold for a great price because I noted its flawless grading—PR69—and I believe that boosted interest. Always include the grade in your title and be prepared to explain why each grade matters as potential buyers will want justification for their investment. Here’s a handy resource to explain coin grades: PCGS Grading Guide.
8 Likes
Check out ‘Coin Swap and Trade’ group and ‘Coin Collectors’ on Facebook! They are quite active and usually have members looking for early releases like yours. Just make sure to read the group rules before posting!
3 Likes
Sold my first early release on eBay and was super nervous! The bidding jumped the last few hours; it was thrilling! I think it’s all about finding the right audience. In my experience, the closer to major coin shows, the better the interest. Just remember to keep your descriptions clear and concise.
6 Likes
Wow, that sounds exciting, @CoinGeek88! I could see how that would be nerve-wracking! I’m hoping for a similar experience when I list my proof coins. Any tips on how many days should I run the auction?
2 Likes
I ran my auction for 7 days, @CoinHustler89. It seemed long enough to create buzz but didn’t drag on too long to lose interest. Ending on a Sunday evening also helped! That’s when most people tend to be online and ready to bid. Best of luck!
5 Likes