Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been deep into the world of V.D.B. (Victor David Brenner) coins lately, particularly the 1909-S penny. I recently snagged a somewhat worn example at a local coin show, and it got me thinking about my purchasing strategies and the common pitfalls I’ve faced along the way.
One thing I’ve learned is to always take a close look at the coin’s condition. The grading can sometimes be subjective, especially in the lower tiers, which can lead to disappointment. I missed out on a beautifully detailed coin last year because I assumed that an MS-64 grade meant it was perfect. Turns out, under a magnifier, there were some noticeable marks that weren’t mentioned! Has anyone else had a similar experience?
For those of you experienced with VDB coins, what tips do you have for avoiding common traps? Are there particular signs of wear or details that are often overlooked? And how do you feel about the authenticity of VDB coins in the marketplace? I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences!
Great topic, @CoinEnthusiast89! I’ve had my fair share of experiences with V.D.B. coins, particularly the 1909-S. It’s crucial to study the grading criteria closely. MS-64 might sound like a good deal, but as you’ve mentioned, those tiny flaws can really affect value. I once bought a coin that was labeled PF-65 only to realize later, under proper lighting, that it had hairline scratches - a definite no-go in the high-end market.
Here are a few tips for anyone buying VDB coins:
- Always use a magnifier: Inspect every surface, particularly the fields for any scratches or imperfections.
- Know the market: Research prices on platforms like PCGS and NGC.
- Authentication is key: Ensure that you're buying from reputable dealers, especially online. Many counterfeit coins circulate out there.
Feel free to reach out if you want to discuss specific coins or sellers!
11 Likes
Couldn’t agree more with your points, @CoinExpert123! I’ve also noticed that many sellers don’t disclose every detail about the coins, especially when it comes to VDBs. I remember purchasing one that looked flawless in pictures but turned out to have significant wear on the reverse that wasn’t visible in the images they posted. Always ask for additional pictures or even a video - it can reveal so much more.
Another thing to consider is the seller’s reputation. I’ve had good experiences with local coin shops too, where you can physically inspect the coin, which is a huge plus!
8 Likes
I’ve had a similar experience, @CoinEnthusiast89! Just last month, I bought a VDB coin and neglected to check under a bright light. It turned out to have a few obvious dings that I completely missed in the shop. I cannot stress enough how important lighting is when assessing coins.
My advice: always use a portable LED light during your inspections to catch those tricky markings!
5 Likes
It’s like a treasure hunt! I’ve been collecting V.D.B. coins for years now and honestly, the thrill of finding a good deal can overshadow some precautions. Just don’t get too caught up in the excitement - double-check those grades. And always keep your receipts and documentation just in case you need to resell in the future!
3 Likes
Thank you all for your insights! I’m definitely taking notes here! The tip about using a portable LED light is especially helpful. I’ll be sure to ask for extra images if I’m buying online, and I must start looking at sellers’ reputations more closely.
6 Likes
Anyone else feel overwhelmed? I’m just starting with VDBs and found the amount of info can be a bit much. Are there any specific resources you guys recommend for beginners? I’d love to dive in but feel a little lost with all the technical details!
2 Likes
No worries, @CollectibleJunkie! We’ve all been there. I’d recommend checking out US Mint for official info and maybe grabbing a book like ‘A Guide Book of United States Coins’ by R.S. Yeoman. It has a wealth of information for beginners!
5 Likes
Great suggestion! @CoinCollectorExpert. Also, don’t hesitate to ask questions here! The community is super helpful, and it’s a great way to learn from each other. VDB coins can be confusing at first, but you’ll get the hang of it with some practice.
4 Likes
Well said, @VintageCollector45! This community is indeed the best. Don’t hesitate to post any specific questions you have, @CollectibleJunkie. We’re all here to help each other out!
2 Likes
Why did the coin collector log out? Because he was tired of all the cents-less arguments! 
But seriously, keep those questions coming. We’re happy to help!
2 Likes