Hey everyone! I’m reaching out to this knowledgeable community because I’ve recently acquired a couple of Saint Gaudens coins that, while stunning, could use a little TLC. I’ve always stuck to the rule of ‘never clean your coins,’ but I feel like these beauties might benefit from some careful attention.
I’ve done some research and learned that several collectors have varying opinions on cleaning—some swear by a simple soap and water method, while others recommend professionally restoring coins. My concern, of course, is maintaining their value. I’ve noticed that both coins have some minor tarnishing and fingerprints, so I’m eager to hear your thoughts. What have your experiences been with cleaning or restoring Saint Gaudens?
Also, if you’ve successfully brought a coin back to life, what methods worked best for you? I know anecdotes can differ widely, but I’m really curious about what precautions I should take. Let’s discuss!
Cleaning coins is a delicate issue, especially for rare pieces like the Saint Gaudens! Personally, I’ve always adhered to the principle of ‘never cleaning coins.’ However, in some extreme cases, I’ve come across methods that are considered less damaging.
- One technique I’ve used is gently immersing the coin in distilled water for a few hours.
- After that, I softly dab it with a microfiber cloth. This helps to remove contaminants without scratching the surface.
I’d highly recommend
not using soap or anything abrasive, as it can cause more harm than good. If you’re uncertain about your cleaning abilities, perhaps a professional restoration service could be a safer route. For valuable coins, preserving the value should be paramount! Check out
PCGS for professional advice on restoration options. Hope this helps!
Also, remember that grading can significantly impact value, and cleaning can alter that perception. Good luck!
— Joe
5 Likes
Hey @CoinEnthusiast99, I totally get your concern about cleaning those beauties! I’ve heard horror stories relating to coin cleaning affecting market value. A couple of years ago, I attempted to clean a 1920 Saint Gaudens using just a mild soap, and I seriously regretted it. I could see tiny scratches on the surface despite being very careful. Now, I use pencil erasers just to lightly buff the surface if needed. It works wonders for removing fingerprints without compromising the coin’s finish! Remember, damage is often subjective, so keep an eye on the market trends if you’re considering selling. 
— Nerd
3 Likes
Thanks for your insights, @NumismaticNerd88! I’m a little nervous about trying anything too aggressive. I never thought about using an eraser—sounds worth a try for those light spots. What kind of eraser do you recommend? Is there a specific brand or type that works best? Thanks again for sharing!
— CoinEnthusiast99
2 Likes
Great tips, @CoinExpertJoe! I’ve always been wary about cleaning, too. A few months back, I picked up a 1908 Saint Gaudens that was a bit tarnished. I decided to have it professionally graded before restorations. They cleaned it for me, and it came back looking like new, without any damage being reported in the grading. I highly recommend getting a second opinion before doing any cleaning yourself!
NGC also has some great resources if you’re looking for reputable restoration services!
— Seeker
4 Likes
LOL, cleaning coins? It’s almost like a taboo in the collecting community! I’ve got a few Saint Gaudens that I let sit untouched in a special display case. Honestly, I think the tarnish gives them character! If you ever think about selling, just remember that buyers often lean towards ‘untouched’ coins. Just my two cents! 
— Chick
2 Likes
Exactly, @CollectorChick! I’ve seen coins with the original tarnish sell for a premium, while cleaned coins often go for less! Natural patina can tell the story of the coin. If you’ve already done research, consider investing in a good display case. It’s a great way to showcase those coins without any risk of unnecessary cleaning!
— Hammer
2 Likes
Great point! @SilverSeeker79 Professional grading and preservation can add value…but be sure to find a reputable service. I’ve had success with US Mint products for storage and cleaning supplies—they can provide some great recommendations! Just don’t go overboard with cleaning; that’s where the trouble starts!
— Mike
3 Likes
It’s important to remember that every coin has its story! If cleaning is necessary, consider simply using a soft brush or an air blower to remove debris without touching the coin’s surface. This can prevent further harm. My own experience with a 1915 Saint Gaudens taught me that it’s sometimes best to keep it in its original state.
Good luck with your cleaning journey!
— Hunter
4 Likes
Really appreciate the varied advice, everyone! Looks like I’ll be trying out the microfiber cloth method mentioned by @CoinExpertJoe and perhaps investing in a display case as @GoldenHammer suggested. I’ll keep you updated on any progress. Also, @CollectorChick, I agree that some tarnish adds character, but I want to make sure they remain in good shape. Thanks again for all the tips!
— CoinEnthusiast99
5 Likes
Couldn’t agree more, @HistoryHunter! Protecting the integrity of our coins is key. When in doubt, less is more! If you ever feel tempted to clean, just take a step back and consider your options. Sometimes, a good display can do wonders without necessitating any cleanup!
— Seeker
3 Likes
One last thought, @CoinEnthusiast99: after any cleaning attempts, definitely have your coins graded! Always take the advice of a professional if you’re unsure. It could save you a lot of heartache down the line if you accidentally reduce their value.
— Connoisseur
2 Likes