Hi fellow collectors! I recently got my hands on a beautiful 1964 Kennedy half dollar that has some stunning rainbow toning. The colors are vibrant, and while I adore the way it looks, I can’t help but wonder how this will impact its grading.
I’ve been doing some research and found mixed opinions on the subject. Some say that rainbow toning can enhance a coin’s appeal and thus its value, while others argue that it may mask wear or detract from the overall grade. I’m curious to hear your thoughts, especially if you’ve sent similar coins in for grading. My coin is in excellent condition otherwise, but I’m unsure if that toning could be a double-edged sword.
Have any of you had experiences with grading rainbow-toned coins? Did it significantly affect the grade you received? I’d love to know how to approach this since the toning adds such character!
Great question, CoinEnthusiast92! I’ve had a few experiences with rainbow-toned coins, and I can share some insights. Color toning can genuinely affect grading, often depending on the grading company’s policies. For example, with companies like PCGS or NGC, they tend to appreciate nice toning as long as it is natural. In my case, I sent in a beautiful
1895 Morgan dollar; it had a vibrant rainbow patina that really enhanced its appeal. I was nervous about how it would grade, but I received an MS66, and the toning was actually highlighted in the description! So, it really depends on the coin and the grading standards.
Also, keep in mind that if the toning seems to cover up any heritage or wear, it might negatively affect your grade. Just my two cents! Check this out for grading standards.
5 Likes
Thanks, SilverStacker88! I appreciate your insights. It’s reassuring to hear that there’s potential for a positive grade even with toning. I’ll definitely look into the links you provided! How long did it take for your coin to get graded? Just trying to gauge the overall timeline here.
2 Likes
Hey there! I’ve had similar experiences with rainbow-toned coins, and in my view, toning can be quite the double-edged sword. Natural toning can enhance a coin’s appeal and potentially increase its value, but if the toning is too dark or uneven, it can mask details that impact the grade.
For example, I once had a 1942 Walker half dollar with gorgeous rainbow toning, but it graded only AU58 because the toning obscured some wear on the edge that I didn’t notice at first. I’d suggest checking out the coin under different lighting conditions and perhaps consulting with a local dealer before sending it off. Just keep it clean, as fingerprints can ruin that beauty! NGC grading guidelines offer some great tips, too!
3 Likes
Thanks for sharing, CoinGuru1984! I hadn’t considered how uneven toning might hide some details. Great advice on looking under different lighting! I’ll definitely be more cautious. By the way, how do you feel about displaying rainbow-toned coins? Do you keep them in special holders?
1 Like
Random thought: Have you checked all the rainbow colors on your coin? Sometimes they can affect the eye appeal differently. I have a 1964 half dollar too, and in good light, the blues and purples pop, but in dimmer lights, it looks dull. Just food for thought! I store mine in Mylar flips, which help with visibility. Haha!
4 Likes
Thanks, NumismatistMike! That’s interesting about how lighting can affect the colors. I’ll have to experiment with my new coin to see how it shows in different types of light. And, yes, I was already thinking of using Mylar flips as they seem to be the best option for displaying without tarnishing until now. How long have you been collecting rainbow-toned coins?
1 Like
Hey, CoinEnthusiast92! I’ve been collecting rainbow-toned coins for about 5 years. Initially, I wasn’t sure if they were a good investment, but the vibrant colors have really grown on me. Plus, I love how each coin has its own personality. Just remember, less is more!
Too much handling can dull those beautiful colors. Keep sharing updates on your coin—can’t wait to see its grading results!
2 Likes
Short answer: From my experience, rainbow toning CAN increase a coin’s value if it’s attractive. Just be wary; some grades can take a hit from funky-looking colors! Always worth getting a second opinion! 
3 Likes
Thanks for the quick tip, TonedCollector77! It sounds like asking for a second opinion can really help if I’m unsure. I’m definitely excited to see how my coin fares. Have you sent any in for grading yourself?
Yes! I sent in a rainbow-toned Barber quarter and got an MS65. Fantastic grade for such a lively appearance. Just keep your expectations realistic; not every coin is going to suit the graders’ fancy!
Best of luck with yours! 
2 Likes