Hey everyone! I’m fairly new to coin collecting and have recently come across some end rolls at my local bank. I’ve been researching how to assess their grading, but it feels a bit overwhelming. These rolls are a mixed bag—I’ve found everything from shiny, almost uncirculated coins to those that are pretty worn down. I’d love to hear from anyone who’s been through this process!
Specifically, how do you determine the condition of coins within end rolls? I’ve read about different grading scales like the Sheldon scale, but practical application seems tricky. For example, I noticed some of the coins have noticeable bag marks while others barely show wear at all. Do you have any tips on balancing visual assessment with grading?
I’m really eager to learn from your experiences! What are your go-to methods for grading? Also, should I buy a loupe for better examination? Any insights would be greatly appreciated as I dive deeper into this part of the hobby!
Welcome to the world of coin collecting! Assessing the grading of coins from end rolls is indeed a fun yet challenging task. Here are some tips:
1. Visual Inspection: Start with a thorough visual inspection under decent lighting. Look for luster and any obvious wear.
2. Sheldon Scale: Familiarize yourself with the Sheldon 1-70 scale. A coin graded 60 is considered uncirculated with some marks, while a coin graded 70 is perfect.
3. Bag Marks: As you noticed, bag marks can heavily influence grading. Coins with heavy marks may drop a grade or two, while those with minimal marks may not suffer as much.
4. Using a Loupe: Absolutely, I recommend getting a loupe! It allows you to see finer details that can change a grade significantly.
5. Reference Sites: Check out the PCGS website for great resources on grading.
Just practice a lot, and you’ll get better with time. Happy collecting!
15 Likes
Thanks for the detailed tips, @NumismaticNerd! I’ll definitely grab a loupe. It’s exciting to evaluate these coins. Any specific signs to look for in uncirculated coins?
5 Likes
Don’t stress too much about it! Grading can be intimidating at first. If you can find a local coin club, they often have members who are happy to help newcomers. Using resources like NGC is also helpful for learning about different grading factors.
Remember to keep your expectations realistic—some coins are just not going to be in mint condition. But they can still hold value or sentimental importance!
10 Likes
Great point, @OldSchoolCollector! I’ve just joined a coin club. I hope to meet some experienced collectors there. 
Any suggestions on questions to ask them?
3 Likes
Another tool is to acquire a grading guide or book! There’s a lot of focus on grading, but understanding the context and market for what you find is equally important. Here’s a quick list of things to consider when grading from end rolls:
- Check for strike weakness – some coins, especially older ones, can have uneven details.
- Look for any corrosion or blemishes that may not be visible without a loupe.
- Consider the Historical context of the coins as some might hold more value irrespective of their condition.
Here’s a great starting guide:
US Mint. Keep practicing, and soon you’ll be confidently grading coins!
12 Likes
I always say, if you’re unsure about a coin’s grade, it’s better to err on the side of caution and grade it lower. @CoinEnthusiast92, it’s a good practice for beginners! Plus, you can upgrade your grade as you learn more about the hobby. Who knows, you could end up with some hidden gems! 
7 Likes
Grading from end rolls can indeed be tricky. Sometimes you’ll find coins that don’t match typical grading consensus. My recommendation? Take photos of the coins as you evaluate them and track your observations. It can be quite enlightening to review your assessments over time—it helps you see how your grading skills have improved!
8 Likes
Love that idea, @ModernCoinsFan! I’ll start documenting my findings. It’ll help track my progress for sure! 
What do you usually note down when grading?
4 Likes
Absolutely true, @Hobbyist77! And don’t forget, it’s all part of the learning experience! You’ll find that each roll might teach you something new. Plus, sharing those coins with other collectors can lead to great discussions and tips.
5 Likes
One humorous thought—sometimes, you just have to remember to enjoy the process! Grab a cold drink, sit down with your end rolls, and enjoy—it’s like a treasure hunt! 
I often find my favorite coins are the ones that don’t have the highest grades, but the most interesting stories!
6 Likes