Hey fellow collectors! As a long-time enthusiast of early 20th-century coins, I’ve been on the hunt for authentic 1909-S pennies lately. This elusive beauty not only has historical significance but also seems to be increasing in value, which gets my collector’s heart racing. I recently came across a couple, but they were either in poor condition or way overpriced. It’s a bit disheartening, to be honest.
I’d love to tap into the community’s wisdom on this—what resources or strategies have you all found most effective for locating genuine 1909-S pennies? Are there specific dealers or online platforms that you trust? I’ve done my fair share of browsing through auction sites, but I’m wary of fakes. I’ve also attended local coin shows, but they can be hit or miss in terms of quality.
For me, condition is key; I prefer coins that show minimal wear but still retain their character. I’m curious to hear your experiences—what does your ideal 1909-S penny look like? Any tips on evaluating authenticity and negotiating a fair price would also be greatly appreciated! Looking forward to your thoughts!
Great topic, @coinhunter87! The 1909-S penny is indeed a treasure! As someone who’s dedicated years to collecting, I recommend starting with reputable dealers who specialize in early coins. One resource I’ve found invaluable is PCGS. They also have a great database for grading coins, which can help you determine if the price you’re seeing is fair.
- Be mindful of condition: MS 65 is ideal, but be prepared for higher costs.
- Check local listings and auctions; heritage auctions can have great finds but verify the seller.
- Attend coin shows and speak to dealers—many are willing to share their expertise.
Always ask for the coin’s grading certification if possible! Good luck!
5 Likes
@numismatist123 makes some excellent points! I would also suggest checking out local forums and Facebook groups where collectors sell their coins. Sometimes, the best deals are found in unexpected places! And don’t forget about estate sales—I’ve found some hidden gems that way. Always carry a magnifying glass to assess the coin closely for key details such as the mint mark!
3 Likes
Hey @coinhunter87! I totally get your concern about authenticity—it’s so important! I recommend sticking to major auction houses like Bonhams or Sotheby’s when you’re serious about buying. They have rigorous checks, and you can often find high-quality pieces! Just be prepared for the bidding war! 
4 Likes
Hey there! I’ve had great luck finding authentic 1909-S pennies on NGC‘s marketplace. Just make sure to review the sellers’ ratings. I also like to attend coin shows early on the first day—best chance to grab desirable coins before they sell out! And always practice your negotiation skills; you’ll impress the dealers! 
2 Likes
@coinlover92 That’s a solid suggestion, but I would caution to check the buyer’s premium, as it can be hefty! Also, if you’re evaluating authenticity, always look for signs of tampering or cleaning. The coin’s surface should be natural; avoid pieces that have obvious rewiring. Have you thought about getting certified coins? It could save you headaches in the future!
3 Likes
Thanks so much for all the tips, everyone! I’ll definitely check out PCGS and NGC more deeply. I hadn’t considered estate sales or local forums—those sound like great ideas! @numismatist123, what do you think about sending coins to NGC for grading? Is it worth the investment for someone who collects as a hobby?
8 Likes
Absolutely, @coinhunter87! Sending coins to NGC or PCGS can add significant value, especially for rarer pieces like the 1909-S. It proves authenticity and grade, which are crucial for any collector. Just keep in mind the fees—it can get pricey. If it’s a coin you plan to keep long-term, it’s definitely worth it!
5 Likes
@coinexpert101 Yes! Always check for those things! I also like to use a jeweler’s loupe when examining the coin; it helps catch finer details. Also, don’t forget to check if the coin has any cleaning marks—coins are often mishandled in cleaning. Your collection deserves the best! 
4 Likes
Hey, @coinhunter87! Just a thought—if you’re really serious about quality, you might want to join a local coin club. They often have resources and established networks for deals that are hard to find! Plus, fellow collectors can offer advice tailored to your area! Near me, the club always has a trading day once a month—what fun! 
3 Likes
Just to add in, @coinhunter87, keep an eye on online marketplaces like Etsy or eBay but always verify the seller’s rating. Sometimes you can find a very good deal there, but filter out the sellers without thorough reviews. Happy hunting!
2 Likes
Thanks again, everyone! I’m really inspired by the suggestions about joining a local coin club and exploring online marketplaces more! I appreciate all your input!
7 Likes