Hey fellow collectors! I’m relatively new to coin collecting, and I recently came across a few Fraser Buffalo coins at a local estate sale. I was immediately struck by the unique design and artistry of these pieces. However, as I started looking closer, I realized there are a number of different variations, and I’m feeling a bit overwhelmed trying to identify them.
Specifically, I’m curious about the key markings and features that can help differentiate the variations. For starters, I’ve noticed differences in the relief of the buffalo and the placement of the date, but I’m sure there’s more to it. I found some resources online, but they didn’t dive into the specifics like I had hoped. Have any of you had experience with this? What resources or tips do you recommend for a rookie like me?
I’d love to hear about your personal experiences when identifying different types of Fraser Buffalo coins. Are there certain markings or traits that are particularly telling? Your insights would be super helpful in my quest to build a robust collection!
Welcome to the world of coin collecting! The Fraser Buffalo, also known as the Indian Head Buffalo nickel, is a beautiful coin with several variations worth noting. The key elements to look for include:
- Date placement - In some variations, the date is closer to the rim or spaced differently.
- Buffalo design - Pay attention to the details on the buffalo. For instance, you might notice variations in the hair detail on his head.
- Mint marks - These can significantly alter a coin’s value; check for the 'D' or 'S' mint marks on the reverse side.
- Strikes - Some coins have a *strong strike* where the details are more pronounced; others may have 'weak' or 'flat' strikes.
I recommend checking the NGC and PCGS databases for more detailed images of the variations, as they can be really useful. When I started collecting these coins, I found it helpful to compare images online side by side, just to get a feel for what to look for. Hope that helps!
NGC has some great resources too!
5 Likes
Thanks, @NumismatistJoe! This is super helpful. I really appreciate the tips on the design differences and knowing about mint marks. I’ll definitely check out those resources you mentioned! Do you have any specific examples of where to look for the variations?
2 Likes
Identifying Fraser Buffalo variations can indeed be tricky! A great resource that I have used since I started is the book ‘A Guide Book of Buffalo Nickels’ by Q. David Bowers. It provides detailed explanations about the variations and has helpful images.
Also, if you come across coins from 1913, there’s the Type 1 and Type 2 variation specifically differentiated by the buffalo’s tail. The Type 1 has a more ‘hidden’ tail which is great to spot. Good luck with your collection, and feel free to share pictures if you find more coins!
3 Likes
I also second @CoinsNerd5 on that book, it’s a fantastic start! I love how in-depth it goes into each of the coin types. For those who are visual learners, YouTube has some great walkthroughs about identifying these coins and their varieties too. Just type in ‘Fraser Buffalo variations’ and you’ll find plenty of content!
4 Likes
Don’t let the variations overwhelm you! Start by focusing on a few key pieces instead of trying to learn about every single one right away. From my experience, when I first started collecting, I picked five specific years to focus on—the differences in coin quality and the technique used were much easier to understand that way.
And honestly, once you get into it, spotting those little details about the Buffalo will become second nature. Just keep at it and enjoy the process!
3 Likes
Great advice, @VintageCoins4U! I think I’ll start with focusing on a few key years. It’s comforting to know that it’ll get easier over time. I’m excited to dive deeper into this collection!
2 Likes
Heads up! Make sure to check the coin angles and lighting when examining them closely. Sometimes you can catch a mint mark or a subtle detail that makes a significant difference under the right light. It’s like a treasure hunt! Good luck with your collecting journey!
1 Like
Haha, @CoinGeek99, I’d call it a treasure hunt too, but let’s be honest, instead of gold, we find ourselves investing in pieces of metal! 
But really, the thrill is in the hunt and the history behind each coin. Fingers crossed you find a rare one!
2 Likes
For quick references, I often use the US Mint site. They’ve got reference images and historical data that can help with identifying your coins. Additionally, don’t forget to check online forums periodically. Sometimes you stumble upon posts that answer your questions in ways you hadn’t thought of. Happy hunting!
3 Likes