Hey everyone! As I dive deeper into my coin collection, I’ve found myself increasingly drawn to key date coins. Recently, I stumbled upon a 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny and have a mix of excitement and anxiety about it. I’ve done my homework, researching its characteristics and history, but I can’t shake the fear of getting duped by a fake or a replica, which seem to be all too common these days.
I’ve read a few articles about how to differentiate between real and counterfeit coins—things like checking for imperfections, weight, and even magnetism—but I’d love to hear some seasoned advice from you all. What are your go-to methods for spotting a fake? How do you ensure you’re making a solid investment, especially when it comes to coins that can cost a small fortune?
I’m all ears for any tips and insights you might have! Have you ever had an experience where you nearly fell for a replica? Let’s share our stories and help each other out in this coin-collecting journey!
Great topic, CoinHunter92! Spotting fakes, especially with key date coins like the 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny, can be a daunting task for many collectors. Key date coins are often targeted for counterfeiting due to their value. Here are some tips that have helped me over the years:
- Check the weight: Authentic coins have very specific weights. For the 1909-S V.D.B. penny, it should weigh around 3.11 grams. If it’s off by a significant margin, it’s likely a fake.
- Look for inconsistencies: Examine the die markers and details closely. Authentic coins will have sharper details than fakes. Use a jeweler’s loupe for close inspections.
- Use the magnet test: While most copper coins are not magnetic, some counterfeits contain metals that are. A simple magnet can save you some heartache!
- Get a second opinion: If you’re ever in doubt, consider getting the coin authenticated by a reputable service like PCGS or NGC.
Additionally, sharing experiences can be immensely valuable. I’ve been near a couple of replica situations, and thankfully I caught them before buying. Always trust your gut and do your homework!
12 Likes
Thanks for the detailed tips, @CoinExpert123! It’s really reassuring to hear about the weight and magnet tests. I never thought about asking for a second opinion, but I guess it can save me a lot of hassle. Have you ever encountered any specific signs that really gave away a counterfeit coin?
5 Likes
I had an experience with a fake 1909-S! I bought a coin that seemed legit until I noticed the weight was off. It turned out to be a replica made from steel instead of copper. After that, I always use a scale before making any purchases. A digital scale can be very useful—definitely recommend that route! Anyone else have stories to share about dodging fakes?
7 Likes
Haha @SilverStash, I feel you! There are so many replicas out there. Just the other day, I walked into a coin shop and saw a dealer trying to sell a fake 1861 Seated Liberty. The texture was way off. Now, I always make sure to feel the coin and check the texture. Counterfeit coins often lack that punchy feel. Have you ever come across any particularly convincing fakes?
6 Likes
When buying key date coins, patience is key. Don’t rush into any deals. Make sure to ask for the coin’s provenance. A respected history can often indicate authenticity. Plus, if the seller isn’t providing any provenance, that’s a huge red flag! Also, consider joining a local coin club. They often have experienced members who can help you avoid pitfalls. Has anyone here been part of a club? What was your experience like?
4 Likes
Good point, @NumismaticNerd. I’ve been thinking about joining a coin club! It seems like a great way to learn and meet people. Do you have any recommendations on how to find a reputable club?
3 Likes
Be careful with online buys! While it’s tempting, a lot of fraud happens on auction sites. Always look for reputable sellers with good feedback, and steer clear of too-good-to-be-true prices. The best deals are often when the seller is unaware of the value. Still, it’s a gamble! I heard a friend lost a lot on an online purchase of what he thought was a genuine 1909-S V.D.B. but was just a clever fake. Check your sources!
9 Likes
I totally agree with @CoinGeek99. I once made a hasty online purchase and ended up with a fake 1877 Indian Head cent. I learned to always check for sellers’ return policies as well. If they’re unwilling to guarantee authenticity, it’s a hard pass for me! It’s better to be safe than sorry. Plus, connecting with local shops is a good idea too.
5 Likes
Thanks for sharing all these experiences! It really makes me more vigilant. I guess whether at coin shops or online, it’s all about trusting your instinct and continuing to educate yourself. Anyone have tips about grading coins when buying? I could use some help with that too!
4 Likes
Grading can be tricky! I recommend familiarizing yourself with Sheldon scale grading. Look at the coin under natural light and at different angles to see wear and luster.
- MS-65: Should show minimal marks.
- PR-70: Pristine condition with zero imperfections.
If possible, compare it to graded coins from
NGC or
PCGS for a visual reference. And practice makes perfect—keep looking at a variety of coins to get the hang of it!
8 Likes