Advice Seeking: I'm thinking of purchasing a coin with a repunched date online, but I'm unsure about the grading. Any tips on assessing its condition before buying?

Design & Varieties Varieties
1

Hey fellow collectors! I’ve recently come across a fascinating piece online—a coin with a repunched date that really caught my eye. It’s an interesting rarity, but when it comes to grading, I’m feeling a bit hesitant. The seller has listed it as VF-20, but I’m not sure if I can take that at face value without seeing it in person.

In my previous research, I’ve discovered that repunched dates can sometimes be tricky to assess, especially when the wear on the coin might obscure the unique features that make it special. I’ve looked at plenty of photos, but they only convey so much. I’m particularly concerned about whether the details of the repunching are visible enough to warrant the asking price.

Have any of you had experiences with similar coins? What tools or methods do you use to evaluate the condition before pulling the trigger on a purchase? I’m curious to know what red flags I should be on the lookout for and even if the grading given by a seller is trustworthy. Any tips or insights would be super helpful!

  • Do you think it’s advisable to ask for more specific images?
  • What markers of grading do you prioritize when assessing details?
  • How do you feel about buying coins online with uncertain grading?
2

Hi CoinGuru42! I completely understand your hesitation. Grading can be very subjective, and VF-20 can vary greatly between different graders, or even between sellers. When dealing with a coin that features a repunched date, I suggest looking closely at the areas around the date for any signs of wear.

  • Make sure the repunching is visible and defined. If the seller has just a stock photo, ask for close-ups of the date area.
  • Check the obverse and reverse for details that might indicate the actual state of the coin. Things like scratch marks or luster will also affect the grade.
Consider using a magnifying glass to examine any potential flaws up close.
Asking for more images is definitely advisable—a reputable seller should be willing to provide them. Good luck with your purchase, and keep us posted on how it goes!
PS: For more info on grading, I recommend PCGS. They have some great resources!

4 Likes
3

Thanks so much for the detailed reply, @NumismaticNerd! I really appreciate the list of tips. I’ll definitely reach out to the seller for more images. It’s good to know there are reliable resources, too. I’ll check out PCGS!

2 Likes
4

Hey there! Picking a coin with a repunched date is always exciting! I’ve had my fair share of runs with them. One thing I always prioritize is the strike quality. If the underlying details that should be visible are lost due to wear, then you’ll likely lose value in that coin down the line. If there’s a visible planchet defect, that’s a huge red flag, too.
I usually compare the coin images against a few reference images available on coin databases or forums. Also, remember, if a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is! Happy hunting!

3 Likes
5

Great advice, @OldTimeCollector! I hadn’t considered the strike quality as much. I’ll keep that in mind when I analyze the images.

1 Like
6

Hey, CoinGuru42! I echo the sentiment about repunched dates! They’re such cool finds. I’ve collected a couple myself. Here’s a quick checklist for you:

  • Look for the clarity of the date and if the repunching detail is evident.
  • Evaluate the overall coin luster and condition - do you see areas that are worn?
  • Consider the seller’s return policy. If they don’t offer returns, that’s often a red flag.
Happy to help if you have any specific images you want to run by us!

2 Likes
7

Thanks, @CoinFancier88! I’ll definitely use your checklist as a guide. I love how everyone in this forum is so supportive! :blush:

1 Like
8

Just a word of caution, CoinGuru42. Many sellers exaggerate their coin’s grade, especially on online platforms. You might want to get a second opinion. I once bought a coin the seller claimed was XF, but when I got it, I was shocked at how worn it actually was! Inspect closely! Like @OldTimeCollector said, if it feels off, it probably is.

2 Likes
9

Thanks for sharing your experience, @CollectorSkeptic! That’s definitely something to keep in mind. I want to avoid surprises when the coin arrives.

2 Likes
10

Just a fun thought! After all this talk about grading, wouldn’t it be cool if we had a grading app that uses AI to evaluate coins? :champagne: Maybe someday we’ll have robots doing our collecting for us! :smile:

3 Likes