Hey everyone! I was browsing through an auction site and stumbled upon a listing for what looks like a VAM coin. At first glance, I was intrigued, but something feels off about the attribution. I’ve been collecting for a while, and I’ve come across my share of misattributed pieces, but this one is particularly puzzling.
I’ve done a bit of research on the specific design features and have compared it with what’s described in the official guides. The die markers don’t seem to match what’s noted for the claimed VAM, and the condition (a MS62) makes it difficult to analyze these details closely. I wonder if anyone here has strategies or resources they use to verify attributions—especially in cases where coins are listed by sellers who might not be well-versed in VAMs.
Are there specific tools or communities you recommend for double-checking attributions? Have you ever encountered a similar situation and what was your approach? I’d love to hear your thoughts and any tips to avoid a costly mistake!
Hey @CoinNerd88,
It sounds like you’re really doing your homework on this VAM coin! Misattributions are not uncommon, especially with VAMs, and I commend you for being cautious. Here are some steps I take to validate attributions:
- Consult the VAM Book: The authoritative Comprehensive Catalog of Morgan and Peace Dollars, 5th Edition by Van Allen and Mallis is a must for identifying die markers.
- Join VAM Communities: Online forums like the VAMWorld are excellent resources. Users often share insights on specific coins and attributions.
- Photographs: Request high-resolution photos from the seller, ensuring they capture the specific die markers critical for VAM attribution.
- Trust Your Instincts: If the features don’t match or the price seems off, don’t hesitate to walk away. There will always be more opportunities.
Have you tried reaching out to other collectors about this specific coin? They might have encountered the same listing and could offer valuable feedback. Good luck!
5 Likes
Thanks for the advice, @CoinExpert101! I hadn’t thought about reaching out to VAM communities! I’ll definitely check out VAMWorld to see if anyone else has insights on this specific coin. Your list of resources is super helpful too. I appreciate the help!
2 Likes
Hey, @CoinNerd88! I can totally relate to your situation. I once bought a VAM coin that turned out to be misattributed, and it was such a hassle. I recommend using the resources on NGC’s site for their comprehensive guides and verification tools. Also, don’t shy away from asking the seller for better images! If they’re uncooperative, that’s usually a red flag. Good luck!
3 Likes
Interesting topic! VAM attributions can be quite tricky. If you have access to a good magnifying glass or a jeweler’s loupe, examine the coin under magnification and compare the details with the die markers listed on PCGS. It can make a world of difference! Sometimes, just getting a second pair of eyes on it, like in your local coin club, can also help. Good luck!
4 Likes
Great tips! Analyzing the coin under magnification sounds essential. I’ll make sure to grab a loupe before I finalize any decisions. Thanks for the input!
1 Like
@CoinNerd88 Don’t be afraid to post images here for feedback! Sometimes, the community can spot things you might miss. Plus, it’s great to engage with other collectors in the process! Good luck. 
2 Likes
Humor Alert! Remember: the only VAM you want to buy is the one with the right attribution… unless you want a new paperweight! 
Seriously though, consider asking for opinions from experts. It might help clear things up quickly.
1 Like
Hey @CoinNerd88,
I’ve been collecting VAMs for a few years, and I’ve used CoinTalk as a resource often. Great community there that’s always willing to help with attribution issues. Just be sure to read up on their rules if you decide to post there! Good luck with your search!
2 Likes
I appreciate all the resources! I’ve gathered a list of communities and sites to check out. This is shaping up to be an enlightening experience! I’ll definitely share my findings once I get more details. Cheers, everyone!
3 Likes
Solid advice! If you have access to a coin dealer, sometimes getting a professional opinion is invaluable. They usually know the current market and can help you avoid misattributions easily. Happy hunting!
1 Like
Thanks, @ClassyCoins! That’s a great idea. I’ll see if I can get in touch with a local dealer. Their expertise could really help with this situation. Awesome tips, everyone!
2 Likes