Hey fellow collectors! I find myself in a bit of a dilemma with my recent decision to part with my 1916-D Mercury Dime. It’s in pretty decent condition with a little wear, but nothing too severe. I’ve been doing some research, and it seems like prices can vary wildly, especially depending on whether it’s sold at auction or through a dealer. The last few sold at auction fetched between $1,200 and $1,800, but I’m not sure if I should take the plunge or play it safe with a dealer who might give me a more stable offer.
I’ve also noticed that some auctions have seen even higher sales for comparable coins, especially if they’re featured prominently or during a big event. However, there’s a risk of the auction not hitting my minimum expectations. Has anyone here sold a 1916-D or faced a similar situation? What were your experiences with auction houses versus dealers? I really want to make sure I’m getting a fair price, but the thought of going through an auction is both exciting and nerve-wracking!
I’d love to hear your strategies and tips for pricing and where you think I should focus my efforts. Have you found any success stories with either method?
Hi @CoinWhisperer42! Selling a 1916-D Mercury Dime is a big deal, and I totally understand your concern about pricing and the selling method. Coin condition plays a significant role in valuation. Since you mentioned yours has some wear but is still in decent condition, it’s good to do a market comparison based on current trends.
- Check auction results on platforms like PCGS or NGC.
- Consider how auction houses market their coins—it can significantly impact final prices.
- Dealers usually offer lower but more reliable prices, which can be appealing if you’re in a hurry.
I recently sold a 1921 Peace Dollar through auction and managed to get 150% of my expected price because it was marketed well.
Bidding wars can be thrilling! Just make sure to set a reserve price if you choose the auction route. What condition is your coin currently graded at? Have you thought about getting it graded? That could also influence your price!
5 Likes
I feel you, @CoinWhisperer42! I faced a similar situation with a 1917-S a while ago. Dealer offers can be quite low, and if you’re not in urgent need of cash, I’d recommend considering an auction. Just make sure you do your homework on the auction house to ensure credibility. I once auctioned a coin with a house that didn’t market it well, and it sold for much less than I expected! My rule of thumb is only auction if you believe in the potential of that bidding war. What’s the grading on your dime? That can make all the difference for your end price.
3 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @CoinGuru99! I haven’t gotten it graded yet—it’s currently in a 2x2 holder. It’s not in great condition, so I’m a bit nervous about how much that might affect its value. Still, hearing your recent auction experience gives me hope! I’ll definitely check out those sites you mentioned.
1 Like
Hey @OldSchoolCollector! That’s a great point about auction houses. Interviews and comparisons are key! I usually prefer using established ones like USMint when selling. Their reputation and advertising help coins go beyond market price. Also, have you thought about online auctions? They have flexibility and reach a broader audience!
2 Likes
Great topic, @CoinWhisperer42! Depending on your urgency and condition, I recommend going through professional grading services. It not only provides more precise valuations but can help enhance buyer trust. Commonly sold Mercury Dimes have averages around $1,250 to $1,600 but can significantly jump if it’s graded AU or higher. If you auction, consider featuring it during a coin show for better visibility. What’s your comfort level with potential auction fees plus shipping costs?
4 Likes
Thanks for the suggestions, @NumismatistPro! I hadn’t considered grading as a way to build trust. I’m still weighing my options, but I guess it’s better to get it graded first before deciding on the selling route. The fees for auctions do worry me a bit, though! What’s a typical range for those?
Hey @CoinWhisperer42! I usually see auction fees ranging from 5% to 15%, depending on the auction house. You want to ensure you know the final price versus the auction hammer price! Just ensure to read the fine print. But if you choose the right house and market it well, the returns could outweigh those costs. It’s all about the strategy going in. How did you come to own your 1916-D?
2 Likes
Good luck, @CoinWhisperer42! I sold my 1916-D last year, and I had a great auction experience! It fetched about $1,700, and I was amazed at the fight among bidders. Just make sure to have attractive photos and a clear description. I had a blast selling mine, even with a little anxiety beforehand! It’s thrilling to watch the bids go up. If you do decide to auction it, let us know how it goes! 
6 Likes
Thanks, @CoinEnthusiast77! That’s inspiring! I’ll be sure to have good pictures ready. Fingers crossed for the same kind of luck! If you have any tips on taking great pictures of coins, I’m all ears! 
1 Like
For photos, @CoinWhisperer42! Make sure to use natural lighting and a plain background. A macro lens helps capture the details. I also use a dark cloth to minimize reflections. Good luck with your sale! Your coin will surely shine! 
3 Likes
Oh, the 1916-D! A classic! Just be cautious with what you decide in terms of value. Some might try low-balling you at a dealer. I’d recommend getting a sense of the market first before making any drastic decisions. Best of luck with the auction or dealer route—either way, you have a beautiful coin! 
3 Likes