Hey everyone! I recently added a Buffalo nickel to my collection—a 1937 DDO, to be specific. When I first spotted it at a local coin shop, I knew it was something special. The doubling on the obverse is pretty pronounced, especially on the “Liberty” and the date. I couldn’t resist picking it up, but now I’m trying to nail down its market value. I’ve seen wildly different prices online!
I’ve done some research and found a few auction listings, but they vary a lot based on condition and just how pronounced the DDO is. Mine is in decent condition with some wear but still shows the doubling clearly. I’m really curious about how the community values such pieces. For anyone who’s dealt with a similar find, what criteria did you use to assess the coin’s value?
I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences! Are there certain marketplaces where you found the best prices? And how much more should a noticeable error command on the market? Looking forward to your insights!
Congratulations on your find! The 1937 Buffalo DDO is indeed a significant collector’s coin. Considering that the value can range significantly based on certain factors, let’s break them down:
- Condition: DDOs in higher grades (like MS66 or higher) can fetch prices well above $1,000, while pieces in VG condition may only get $50-$100.
- Market Demand: If there’s a relatively high demand, especially among collectors who focus on errors, that could also impact your pricing.
- Doubling Visibility: Since you mentioned that the doubling is pronounced, this should definitely enhance your coin’s value, but specific pricing varies by marketplace.
I recommend checking out
PCGS and
NGC for grading and sales reports to assess current trends. Let me know if you have any more questions about grading!
4 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @CoinExpert73! That breakdown helps a lot. Based on the condition of my coin, I’d guess it’s around VF. I’ll definitely check those sites for recent sales!
Buffalo nickels are such a great denomination to collect! I’ve got a few myself, including a DDO from 1936. Those pieces truly sparkle in a collection! For market value, I’ve noticed that Ebay tends to have a wide price variation. Sometimes you can spot amazing deals; other times, the prices are inflated. Make sure to compare similar listings to get a fair assessment!
2 Likes
Absolutely! @NumismaticNerd, I had a similar experience on Ebay. I found a 1938 DDO listed for $300 and got it for only $150. Just keep a keen eye and don’t rush into high-priced listings unless you really feel it’s worth it. It’s amazing how much the market can fluctuate!
3 Likes
Keep in mind the importance of forums! Engaging with communities like ours can keep you updated on trends and help you avoid common pitfalls in pricing. Just a few months ago, I traded my 1937 DDO for a couple of 1909 SVDB pennies and it was the best decision! Each market is unique; sometimes local shops give better values if you have a relationship with them. How are you planning to showcase your Buffalo nickel?
1 Like
Great point, @OldSchoolCollector! I might just frame it along with some other favorite coins. What would you suggest for protecting it while still showing it off?
If you’re framing it, make sure to use an acid-free matting and UV-protective glass! It really helps in keeping the coin in good shape. I got some great advice on that from USMint, and it’s been a game-changer for my collection!
5 Likes
That’s fantastic, @CoinHunter42! I love seeing how people display their collections. I personally use a coin album with clear pages; it protects while still allowing easy viewing. Just be careful with fingerprints! Any chance you’ll take it to a coin show?
2 Likes
Why did the coin collector buy the buffalo nickel? Because it had ‘good horns’! 
But seriously, it’s amazing how much community engagement can enjoy the hobby. Anyone else got a good coin joke?
1 Like