Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Fake or not? (1720 gold 2 roubles)

CoinPeople.com > Specialized Numismatic Forums > Russian Coin Forums
bobh
Looks suspicious:

L I N K
gxseries
Tricky isn't it? I personally avoid collecting such gold coins. If I would want to buy one, I would rather buy one from an auction house.

I personally cannot find faults with that gold coin at the moment...
grivna1726
user posted image user posted image

Winning bid: EUR 2,410.00 (Approximately US $3,048.17)

I don't know if it's real or not, but the bidders seem to think it is.

Prices are amazing these days.
bobh
In the meantime, I have had some feedback from RW Julian about this coin. He believes it is probably genuine, and he sent me scans of a similar coin which was sold in the auction of Giessener Münzhandlung (106). I have copied these scans to my server for you to see:

http://homepage.hispeed.ch/coinsareforever...s/1720gm109.jpg

The scans are from B&W printed matter and aren't very pretty, but you can at least see much of the detail.
grivna1726
QUOTE(bobh @ Jun 10 2006, 05:51 AM)
...I have had some feedback from RW Julian about this coin. He believes it is probably genuine...
[right][snapback]224423[/snapback][/right]


Julian is probably right, but I think you are wise to question coins, especially scarce to rare Russian coins offered on ebay. There are many fakes offered there or coins offered for sale that the "seller" does not own.

I think you can often safely say that a coin is false just by looking at a picture, particularly if it is not well-made. Saying a coin is genuine based only on a picture is far more dangerous.

I agree with the "probably genuine" assessment (based upon the style of the coin), but fakes are getting better and there is still the possibility that it is false.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.