Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Proof versus Uncirculated

CoinPeople.com > Main Numismatic Forums > Coin Forum
jlueke
I've been favoring the more subtle look of uncirculated coins more and more over the highly polished proofs. But this is one proof that I'll make an exception for smile.gif

http://www.coinpeople.com/1972-Bahmas-2-Do...roof-t7100.html

Do you guys prefer buisiness strikes or proofs?
Art
I usually prefer Unc vs Proof. I do think that the proofs are prettier but since they're not made for circulation they don't fit my general collection direction.
bill
Nothing beats a well made, well preserved proof. They reveal the full beauty the artist intended. To my eye, most of the state quarters are ho-hum designs (not all, most). Take those same designs, strike them in silver proof and the number of good designs increases dramatically.
Stujoe
I am a business strike guy for my collections for the most part. But, I enjoy the occasional proof for beauty or when I can't get a business strike. wink.gif
bustchaser
Real coins, not mint collectables.
BiggAndyy
Odd, the business strikes are made from cheap metal that have no intrinsic value, only value via fiat. The proofs are much more likely to be made of a metal that is, historically, negotiable for debts and has intrinsic worth, but the proofs are much less desireable in many collections.

Stranger still is that the only way to get the tokens (coins) made from valuable metal is to trade coins made from a valueless metal.

Makes you think...
AuldFartte
Neat cameo on that one smile.gif

I usually prefer to put business strikes in my type sets. I do, however, pick up a few proofs from time to time because of the cameo.
Ętheling
I like VF/EF coins. Circulation strikes being the main interest as there's not much available [ahem] proof-wise in the 12th century.
Sir Sisu
I used to actively collect proofs. However, I have slowly lost my interest in them through the years. So business strikes are definitely my preference.

There are only 4 proof series that I still actively collect:
-Finland commemoratives
-Finland mint sets
-US mint sets
-US SAEs

If I purchase a proof outside of this, it will be purely on a simple: WOW! I like the look of that! basis. --like the "Rulers of Lithuania" series I bought some time ago.
Tiffibunny
I like both business strikes and proofs and actively collect both. To me the proof is the bling of the coin world. blol.gif
ccg
UNCs usually. I will sticks proofs into my type set where affordable.
joanjet
I am in agreement with Tiffibunny.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.