Lately, I've spent some time studying early copper cents as I try to decide my next collection.

So I have to ask--why is there so much variance in the grading of large copper cents, such as the Draped Bust type? For example, here is one version of F-12 (under two light sources):



And yet another "F-12":



A rather noticeable difference that makes me question the grading skills (or honesty) of sellers.
Is it because the average person cannot recognize the correct grading that sellers fudge a bit?
Are buying certified coins the only reasonable approach?

(((correct grading that sellers fudge a bit)))

Hi Kurt,

When I am trying to grade a coin using the 'Photograde' book I tend to under grade my own coins.
I can see where someone would give a coin a better grade than the coin seems to deserve.
The 1797 draped you show seems to me to be VG-8 obverse because of the lack of definition in the hair that I believe the F-12 should command. Yet, the lettering is still quite sharp. This means one has to chose between the hair and the lettering, and I opt for better definition in the hair and overall for the F-12 grade.

Yes, greed, or as it is otherwise called 'supply and demand', is a big factor in the selling of anything. The lack of knowledge is probably the second most problem in grading coins. The main point is that you noticed the difference and I bet you would not be willing to pay the same price for the 1797 as the other coin, even if they were certified.

Have fun!
Corky

Thanks for your comment. Personally, I think good detail on the obverse is more important aesthetically. I have a lot more to learn about this series before I make any decisions...thanks for your helpful feedback!