Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ancient Japanese error coin

CoinPeople.com > Specialized Numismatic Forums > Error and Variety Coin Forums
gxseries
IPB Image

A coin used during the Nagasaki trading era (1659-1685)

What kind of error do you call this? Double struck? Misstrike? confused1.gif
thedeadpoint
Of course I have no good knowledge but based on the pic, the coin may have been sitting in a pile with other coins of other sizes. Maybe the oxidation of one smaller coin contaminated yours because they were on top of each other in a pile for years.

Know what I mean? I'm really tired.
thedeadpoint
I may be mistaken if there is any sort of relief or dimensionality to the coin where the "double struck" comes in.
ccg
QUOTE(thedeadpoint @ Oct 30 2006, 12:26 AM) [snapback]268804[/snapback]

Of course I have no good knowledge but based on the pic, the coin may have been sitting in a pile with other coins of other sizes. Maybe the oxidation of one smaller coin contaminated yours because they were on top of each other in a pile for years.


Seconded.

Being a cast coin it would rule out a "strike" error.

-Is the 1600s really ancient? The Romans must be pre-historic, then! grin.gif
Scottishmoney
QUOTE(gxseries @ Oct 29 2006, 11:22 PM) [snapback]268788[/snapback]

IPB Image

A coin used during the Nagasaki trading era (1659-1685)

What kind of error do you call this? Double struck? Misstrike? confused1.gif



These coins were not struck, but cast in molds. Iron examples were known as tane or seed coins and are found occasionally. The seed coins were used to make the molds that the bronze was cast in. My guess is that the tane was misapplied in this case, leaving a mark in the mold for the next coin to be cast. Japan used this method of coin manufacture for bronze Mon coins until the 1860's when everything was completely modernised and monetary reform was instituted.
gxseries
I don't believe the "error" is due to corrosion damage.

Here is another better quality image:

IPB Image

And with the same image under negative filter,

IPB Image

It rules out intentional damage I think.

Scottishmoney is right - I wasn't thinking about the minting technology back then. doh.gif Would the proper technical term for this be mold casting error?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.