Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: 1918/7-D Buffalo nickel

CoinPeople.com > Specialized Numismatic Forums > Error and Variety Coin Forums
syzygy
I have had a cold all weekend, but these little red pills help a lot - help the cold, but not necessarily my judgement smile.gif

So, I was looking over some buffalos and came across this one:


IPB Image


When I look at it under certain angles, it does look a bit...a tad...with some imagination...and maybe a touch of denial...and some cold medicine...like the overdate! Here are a couple of close-ups - the best I can do with my old 4M cam.


IPB Image

IPB Image

IPB Image


The diagnostics that I can find online mention 1) the mint mark position: the right side of 'E' on the same vertical as the left side of 'D' and 2) a small die crack above the braid.

Well, the mintmark definitely fits and another 1918-D I have has the mintmark much further to the right than this one. But the reverse die could have been used with many 1918s not just the overdate.


IPB Image


Here is the die crack. On my coin it is plain as day. Problem is, I can't even see a crack on other pics I have been able to find online, so I don't even know if this one is in the right position.


IPB Image


Ok, it is probably *not* the overdate, still I will keep it. Maybe just for S&G, I will take to the next Baltimore show and have an 'expert' look at it over.
ccg
Not sure what to say. First pic last digit looks like a 6, but like an 8 on the others.
syzygy
I looked up the die break diagnostic in a book today at the coin shop - it is a small hairline crack just above the tie on the brain - looks nothing like the die crack on my coin. So much for that. Yeah, I know what you mean that it looks like a six sometimes - I think it is just a normal 1918-D.

dacoinman
From comparing it to a certified one on ebay, it appears to be a normal 18-d. On the over date, the insides of the 8 are somewhat diagonal from each other instead of straight up and down. The auction isn't mine, but I thought I would include the link so you can see what I am talking about. 1918-d/7

On another note, many times has my heart went boom boom thinking that I had a SWEET thing, and it turned out later to only be the normal coin. So, I laugh not at you, but with you. biggrin.gif
tommyd
IPB Image
IPB Image

This is mine and it's genuine -- I believe that only one reverse die was used and that the position of the mm is as such, slightly slanted.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.